Investigators for the FBI and the Hocking County Sheriff spent Monday searching a rental property on Walnut Dowler Road in Hocking County, Ohio. Forensic evidence was recovered leading investigators to believe a crime was committed there.
According to Hocking County Sheriff Lanny North, “They found some forensic evidence which they feel might be linked to a crime scene, to a death. Until it is examined by the lab, they can’t be exactly sure what it is.”
Columbus Police believe the murder of Hailey Buzbee occurred at the rental property in Hocking County.
On Sunday, Tyler Thomas led FBI and local investigators to a location where Hailey Buzbee’s remains were discovered. The body of Hailey Buzbee was buried near a trailhead in Wayne National Forest in Perry County, Ohio.
After an autopsy by the Licking County Coroner’s Office, a report was sent to the Perry County Coroner. Perry County officials have not said when the report will be released.
The Hocking County Sheriff’s timeline shows Hailey Buzbee was reported missing on January 6 and Tyler Thomas was identified as a suspect in her disappearance. On January 16, Buzbee was tracked to Columbus. Columbus Police questioned Thomas who admitted he picked her up in Fishers, Indiana, but dropped her off in western Ohio. Police determined he lied about dropping Buzbee off. On January 20, Thomas was tracked to a rental in Hocking County. The Hocking County Sheriff and the FBI searched the Hocking County rental. On Sunday, Thomas led investigators to Buzbee’s remains. On Monday, the Hocking County rental was searched again and more evidence was discovered.
Authorities say Tyler Thomas and Haley Buzbee stayed at his Victorian Village home on Hunter Avenue in Columbus before later spending time at the short term rental in Logan, Ohio.
While aspects of the timeline are becoming clearer, specific dates and locations are still very much a mystery. It appears investigators zeroed in on Tyler Thomas almost immediately. According to Fox 59, during the Sunday press conference, Chief Ed Gebhart said Fishers Police encountered Thomas within days of Hailey Buzbee being missing. Investigators have stated that they believe Buzbee died within days after her disappearance. When was this initial encounter with Thomas in relation to him taking Buzbee from the Hunter Avenue location to Logan, Ohio?
Another big question looms over this tragedy. Regardless of whether the 39-year-old Tyler Thomas dropped Hailey Buzbee off in western Ohio, why isn’t an older man transporting a missing minor across state lines grounds for an extended round of questioning in the Columbus Police Department interrogation room? In nearly all these cases where a minor goes missing in the company of someone they met online, the missing minor is considered to be in danger. Why was it weeks before that became the case here?
Hopefully we’ll get those answers soon.
Sources:
Columbus Dispatch
WRTV Indianapolis
ABC 6 Columbus
10WBNS Columbus
Fox 59 Indianapolis
